shill

Share on TwitterShare on TumblrSubmit to StumbleUponDigg ThisSubmit to redditShare via email
penny auctions for sale

It’s been just over 3 years since penny auctions came to the US, and after 3 years I still find penny auctions that are using automated bot bidders to bid against real paying penny auction bidders.

Quite frankly I am tired of this practice being allowed at all on the Internet. Yet just today I found yet another person advertising how great and profitable the penny auction business model is, especially because you can steal from paying users.

 Whoever thinks bot bidding is not theft is clearly not thinking correctly. Entrepreneurs who succeed by lying and cheating are not entrepreneurs at all.

Flippa is a popular platform that allows users to buy and sell websites. Today I came across an ad for the sale of the penny auction site GizmoBids.com.

Though they state that they site does not yet generate much profit or traffic, to appeal to would be buyers they go on to explain just how easy it can be to make money by running the site.

From the penny auction ad:

penny auctions scam

“The profitability of the site can be missed by some, but is easy to explain.

Each Credit costs the bidder 10p or as defined by you . Credits are used to increase the price of an “auction” by 1p and can be redefined by the admin.

We also have a auto bidder on the website so if the item doesn’t make the money to cover the item the website wil bid until the right price is made.”

Reminds me of this penny auction owner who took pride in stealing from penny auction bidders.

One interested user asked if it was legal to run the penny auction site in Canada. The seller replied by telling him that it was legal. I hope that all interested penny auction owners know that by using auto bidders, by manually shill bidding, you are cheating consumers and that is clearly not legal.

In fact the developer who created the penny auction script that is on GizmoBids came under fire in the United Kingdom by the Office of Fair Trading, they made it clear that using bots to bid against paying consumers is illegal.

UK Office of Fair Trading Cracks Down on Penny Auction Script with Bot Option

 Not all penny auctions cheat, but it’s really hard to know for sure whether or not a penny auction is legitimate, so just keep this in mind if you plan to bid on any penny auction site. 

The Entertainment Auction Association was set up to bring credibility to the penny auction industry by calling on legit penny auctions to get audited and agree to follow a code of conduct that excludes dishonesty such as shill bidding. If you’re interested in starting a penny auction and running a legit business definitely check it out.

In case you’re looking for more information on penny auctions, join our free penny auction forum.

{ 2 comments }

Does the Entertainment Shopping Industry Have the Potential to Reinitiate the Online Auction?

penny auctions June 30, 2011

Today, Norwegian entrepreneur Tore Rasmussen, who will soon, with his partner Vegard Kjelseth open an entertainment shopping site, wrote an article on The Evolution of Online Auctions which comments on James Surowiecki’s “Going, Going, Gone: Who Killed the Internet Auction?” Wired.com article. Tore mentioned that James forgot to include penny auction sites and other revolutionary forms of [...]

Read the full article→

More Penny Auction Testimonials That Seem Fake: Biduh & MixBids

Thumbnail image for More Penny Auction Testimonials That Seem Fake: Biduh & MixBids June 23, 2011

Last week we posted about what seemed to be fake testimonials being used by the new penny auction site BidNuke.com. We showed you the  feedback that appeared to have been left by “jknate,” someone affiliated with or running the penny auction,  on many Fiverr.com ads for fake testimonials/reviews. We also matched up one of their [...]

Read the full article→

Does BidSlasher Bid & Win Their Own Items? Shill Bidding Alleged

bidslasher February 16, 2011

Have you bid on BidSlasher.com? Apparently 2 PAW forum members that share IP addresses with BidSlasher’s PAW forum account do, and they’ve won too. First, let’s take a look at what our members have been saying about BidSlasher: Comments posted from 2/8- present “Stuff goes SO low on this site, EXCEPT when I decide to [...]

Read the full article→

PoshBid is Back & Users Still Need Their Items

February 12, 2011

Estonia based penny auction PoshBid.com is back again, but their domain is for sale ($1,200) and users are reporting they still haven’t received items from as far back as 2009. In 2009 PAW members liked PoshBid, well, for a while, that was until the delays in shipping and items were allegedly shipped to winners from [...]

Read the full article→

Updated BidWat Responds: BidWat Allegedly Posted Shill Reviews in the Penny Auction Watch Forum

bidwat January 14, 2011

2nd Update 2/7: It appears BidWat has pulled the YouTube videos. Update: Bidwat’s owner has posted videos responding to this post and apologizes for “shill” reviews, he requested that we post the videos here: : Recently penny auction site Bidwat.com inquired about advertising on this site, however, due diligence had to first be done before [...]

Read the full article→

Entertainment Auction Association Formed

eaa December 8, 2010

It’s been a while since good news was shared here on the penny auction industry, and I know a few critics have said this site is pretty negative, and unfortunately this is not without reason. There are shady operators that are, and have been, ripping consumers off and giving the entire penny auction industry a [...]

Read the full article→

Our Totally Free Practice & Demonstration Penny “Auction” Site Launches Today!

shillo December 6, 2010

UPDATE 12/18/10: JONATHAN SMITH OF PENNYAUCTIONCOMMUNITY.com FORMERLY MIDPENNY.COM sold the Shillo.com script to me illegally when I asked him if he had resale rights. He sold it to me anyway and he was not entitled to do so. I did not have the right to purchase the software according to Scriptmatix, and apologize to Scriptmatix [...]

Read the full article→

Investigation Into All Penny Auction Sites is Imperative

walle December 5, 2010

With developers making bot scripts readily available and even packaged into their software they sell, it’s easy for penny auction sites to siphon money from hundreds if not thousands of customers, who’s to say that they even have to ship ANY items? In a previous post we published “Requesting An Explanation,” in it was presented [...]

Read the full article→

BidzHut.com Shills Then Cusses Me Out

cussing November 18, 2010

So, I sat down to check the morning e-mails and wanted to share with you how I was greeted by a penny auction site owner, hope it brightens your day as it did mine: First, BidzHut.com’s owner joined the forum and started posting multiple times all over the forum to promote spam his penny auction [...]

Read the full article→

User With Same IP as Steve At SlamPenny.com Posts That He’s Won Items?

slampenny November 17, 2010

Have you bid on SlamPenny.com ? Apparently someone with the site owner’s IP has. Today we received an e-mail from Steve[@]SlamPenny.com from the following IP: 68.99.79.5. Shortly afterwards forum member e6usa registers and posts the following 2 comments (1 after the other since it was still in moderation): “Has nayone else found slampenny.com? It looks legit [...]

Read the full article→

What Have Your Experiences Been With GeekBids.com?

geekbids November 8, 2010

Penny auction GeekBids.com states that they’re a family owned company based in North Carolina. They list 513 ended auctions. Site information: Registrar: FastDomain Inc. Provider Name….: HostMonster.Com Provider Whois…: whois.hostmonster.com Provider Homepage: http://www.hostmonster.com/ Business name: Can’t seem to find one. Alexa Ranking: “Geekbids.com’s three-month global Alexa traffic rank is 5,486,677.” Technical information: Script currently being used- The ProtoPenny script by Nash Brooklyn, this [...]

Read the full article→

Should Friends Bid?

friends November 3, 2010

In the terms & conditions of many penny auctions it states that employees & relatives cannot bid on their penny auctions, but what about friends? This is something that has been concerning us lately, as it’s been found that friends of owners have been bidding (sometimes heavily, too) on their sites. One site was even [...]

Read the full article→

Why Do Penny Auction Sites Close?

penny auctions out of business October 13, 2010

When looking back over the last year and a half there sure have been a lot of penny auctions site that have come and gone, the Penny Auction Watch℠ Out-of-Business Penny Auction site list hasn’t been updated in awhile, but at least another dozen sites can be added to the list of the sites that [...]

Read the full article→

Washington Attorney General Steps Up to the Plate Holds Shill Penny Auction Accountable

thumbs up September 28, 2010

On January 18th of this year we found PennyBiddr.com shill bidding, well thanks to a referral from the FTC  the Washington Attorney General is holding them accountable. It’s about time! There are many more sites that are shill bidding and we hope that consumers will report these sites so that everyone who has been defrauded [...]

Read the full article→

Stop Committing Fraud! We’re Tired of It!

fraud tshirt September 21, 2010

Both Bidtimelive.com and Bidtime25.com are now gone, they haven’t responded to customers in months and they haven’t shipped out owed items. Why not? When speaking with Jay at Bidtime a few months back he told us that all customers would be taken care of, it’s been over 4 months now and still there are customers [...]

Read the full article→

Oversight is Necessary

oversight approval September 17, 2010

Over the course of the last 19 months we’ve found many penny auction sites that have done the following dishonest and/or fraudulent acts: Shill bid (bid against their paying bidders, either with software to do this, or manually). Failed to ship items out, some have even relished in this. A violation of the Consumer Protection [...]

Read the full article→

Is BiditQuick.com Legit?

Thumbnail image for Is BiditQuick.com Legit? August 31, 2010

With over 15 active auctions ending right now, with an average retail price of nearly $1200, BiditQuick.com (also MyQuickBid.com) states that they are the “#1 Penny Auction Site,”  It’s clearly of their opinion that they are the “#1 penny auction site.” On each active auction the timers are basically in sync, what could this mean? [...]

Read the full article→

MyLuckyBids’ Pleas of Desperation When Shill Bot Script Breaks!

Thumbnail image for MyLuckyBids’ Pleas of Desperation When Shill Bot Script Breaks! August 20, 2010

How the newest member of the PAW Hall of Shame got there: MyLuckyBids.net/.com Remember a few months ago we wrote about penny auction site MyLuckyBids.com/.net and pointed out that the script they were using, PHPPennyAuction script allowed for bot bidders?” Apparently they’re a bit biased towards their own site and claim that they are the “safest [...]

Read the full article→

What Was Your First Impression?

penny auctions wow August 19, 2010

When you first found penny auctions what was going on in your head? Obviously you were curious, maybe that ad you found for a hot gadget for pennies was what reeled you in, or maybe it was an advertorial in the form of a “consumer tips website,” (questionable form of marketing, in our opinion), maybe [...]

Read the full article→